TY - JOUR

T1 - Associations Between Self-Disorders and First-Rank Symptoms

T2 - An Empirical study

AU - Nordgaard, Julie

AU - Henriksen, Mads Gram

AU - Berge, Jonas

AU - Nilsson, Lars Siersbæk

PY - 2020

Y1 - 2020

N2 - Background: The diagnostic weight of the first-rank symptoms was deemphasized in DSM-5 and a similar change is expected in ICD-11. This change was motivated by a lack of solid, empirical evidence of the diagnostic significance of first-rank symptoms for schizophrenia. Yet, it seems that Schneider’s original concept of first-rank symptoms was overly simplified when it was introduced in DSM-III. Specifically, it was overlooked that first-rank symptoms, in Schneider’s understanding, fundamentally involve a disorder of the self. The aim here is to empirically test Schneider’s claim that first-rank symptoms involve self-disorders. Methods: In a modified, cross-sectional study of 98 first-admission patients, the relation between lifetime presence of first-rank symptoms and self-disorders was examined. Self-disorders were examined with the EASE (Examination of Anomalous Self-Experiences). Results: We found an odds ratio of 1.56 (95% CI 1.10–2.21) for having first-rank symptoms for each 5-point increase in the EASE (measuring self-disorder) using a generalized linear mixed model regression. We did not find first-rank symptoms in the absence of self-disorders. Conclusion: The close relation between first-rank symptoms and self-disorders seems to support Schneider’s original concept of first-rank symptoms. We suggest that first-rank symptoms occurring without the pervasively altered self-experiences might not be different from other psychotic phenomena in terms of their diagnostic significance. Awareness of self-disorders can help clinicians in assessing and detecting first-rank symptoms.

AB - Background: The diagnostic weight of the first-rank symptoms was deemphasized in DSM-5 and a similar change is expected in ICD-11. This change was motivated by a lack of solid, empirical evidence of the diagnostic significance of first-rank symptoms for schizophrenia. Yet, it seems that Schneider’s original concept of first-rank symptoms was overly simplified when it was introduced in DSM-III. Specifically, it was overlooked that first-rank symptoms, in Schneider’s understanding, fundamentally involve a disorder of the self. The aim here is to empirically test Schneider’s claim that first-rank symptoms involve self-disorders. Methods: In a modified, cross-sectional study of 98 first-admission patients, the relation between lifetime presence of first-rank symptoms and self-disorders was examined. Self-disorders were examined with the EASE (Examination of Anomalous Self-Experiences). Results: We found an odds ratio of 1.56 (95% CI 1.10–2.21) for having first-rank symptoms for each 5-point increase in the EASE (measuring self-disorder) using a generalized linear mixed model regression. We did not find first-rank symptoms in the absence of self-disorders. Conclusion: The close relation between first-rank symptoms and self-disorders seems to support Schneider’s original concept of first-rank symptoms. We suggest that first-rank symptoms occurring without the pervasively altered self-experiences might not be different from other psychotic phenomena in terms of their diagnostic significance. Awareness of self-disorders can help clinicians in assessing and detecting first-rank symptoms.

U2 - 10.1159/000508189

DO - 10.1159/000508189

M3 - Journal article

C2 - 32610320

VL - 53

SP - 103

EP - 110

JO - Psychopathology

JF - Psychopathology

SN - 0254-4962

IS - 2

ER -